800-450-6118

Carpal Tunnel Gloves

Dr. Z • Sep 19, 2021

Guide to Carpal Tunnel Gloves

Patients always ask about carpal tunnel gloves and how good they really are. Basically, there are two types of gloves:


  • Ordinary carpal tunnel gloves
  • Carpal tunnel compression gloves


There's a big difference between these two products. In fact, you should never use carpal tunnel compression gloves if you have carpal tunnel syndrome. The following article explains everything you need to know to help eliminate the pain, numbness, and tingling of this disorder.


Contents of this article:

  • What gloves can do for carpal tunnel syndrome
  • Why some patients are helped by carpal tunnel gloves
  • Which carpal tunnel gloves help
  • Which carpal tunnel gloves to avoid
  • The dangers of compression gloves
  • Using wrist braces
carpal tunnel gloves

What gloves can do for carpal tunnel syndrome

Carpal tunnel syndrome is a type of peripheral neuropathy. That means there is a damaged nerve inside your wrist joint. The damage to the nerve causes unusual sensations like pain, numbness, tingling (pins-and-needles), burning, itching, shooting electric shocks, weakness, and clumsiness.


Nobody knows for sure why that nerve, the median nerve, gets damaged in the first place. But we know that people in certain occupations are prone to getting this disorder.


 Want to know how severe your carpal tunnel really is?

 Take this 60 second Quiz designed by Dr. Z.

pins & needles

These occupations all have one thing in common: they require rapid, repetitive or forceful use of the hands or fingers. That's why the following professions are prone to getting carpal tunnel syndrome:


pregnant woman reclining

Added to that, people are also at particularly high risk for developing carpal tunnel syndrome if they meet one or more of the following scenarios:


man thinking

Why some patients are helped by carpal tunnel gloves

 Carpal tunnel gloves are among the most popular products available to patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. There are 4 reasons for their popularity:

1. Warmth

Gloves keep your hands warm - and this is good! Warmth helps the body heal. And since the median nerve is damaged inside the wrist joint, keeping your hand and wrist warm will speed the nerve's healing.

2. Placebo effect

The gloves have a tremendous placebo effect, especially on pain. The placebo effect reduces pain temporarily. But within hours, the pain returns as the effect wears off. The placebo effect is especially strong with "compression gloves" (see below). The constant compression "reminds" you that you're wearing something that's supposed to help ease the pain. And therefore it does - temporarily.

placebo effect cartoon

3. They're cheap

Most carpal tunnel gloves cost under $25. But considering the fact that they're merely ordinary hand gloves, the cost is actually high. Also, paying top dollar for a "therapy product" adds to its credibility, which helps feed the placebo effect. And most companies will do or say anything (including lying about a product's effectiveness) to grab a piece of the $60 billion pain market.

4. Hype

Carpal tunnel gloves are greatly hyped. Most companies even resort to false advertising to pump up the hype. In reality, any glove that advertises "helps carpal tunnel syndrome" is false advertising. That's because NO research to date has tested the clinical effects of gloves on this disorder. Therefore, such a claim is a lie - and illegal. (Companies promoting "copper infused" gloves are telling the biggest lies - see below.)

Bottom Line: Do carpal tunnel gloves really work?


Not really. Keeping your hand warm helps your body heal the damaged median nerve (which causes carpal tunnel syndrome). But aside from providing some warmth, there is NO other benefit to wearing a carpal tunnel glove.

gloves

Which carpal tunnel gloves help - if even a little

Once again, gloves don't provide much therapy for carpal tunnel syndrome. The most powerful result of wearing a carpal tunnel glove is the placebo effect.


But the small benefit of keeping your hand warm can be gained by wearing just about ANY hand glove, and not necessarily a "carpal tunnel glove". So why spend the extra money?


Therefore, if you insist on wearing  a glove for your carpal tunnel syndrome, buy an inexpensive thermal glove from your local clothing store or online. Remember, it doesn't matter if it's not a "carpal tunnel glove".


And avoid compression gloves at all costs (see below).

compression gloves

Which carpal tunnel gloves to avoid - and are dangerous

The manufacturers of carpal tunnel gloves listed below make outrageous claims. It's false advertising, and also illegal. Eventually, the Federal Trade Commission will catch up, and force them stop making the false claims.


Also, remember to avoid using compression gloves. They will worsen carpal tunnel syndrome. Therefore, specifically avoid products sold as:


  • Copper Fit
  • Imak
  • Kapmore
  • Mediven
  • Ironclad
  • Vive
  • Dr. Frederick’s

The dangers of compression gloves

Nerve compression causes carpal tunnel syndrome

The reason you have carpal tunnel syndrome is because of nerve compression. The median nerve is squeezed and compressed inside your wrist joint. The compression is what causes all of the symptoms like finger or hand pain, numbness, shooting electric shocks, weakness, and tingling.


So why would you ADD compression to your hand? The compression transmits to the wrist's interior and makes the situation much worse. This is why compression gloves are harmful if you have carpal tunnel syndrome.


So if the manufacturers claim their gloves "relieve carpal tunnel pain", it's a lie -- and false advertising.

Arthritis gloves actually help



Note that compression gloves DO work for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. The gloves compress the hand and squeeze away excess fluid, which can be painful in arthritic joints.


But RA is much different than carpal tunnel syndrome. Compressing your hand will exert more pressure on your median nerve. And that makes carpal tunnel symptoms worse.


COPPER FIT FAKE CLAIMS

The copper scam


Many companies promote the use of COPPER in their gloves. But copper has ZERO therapeutic benefit. Yet it sounds so scientific!


Actually, any doctor will tell you such claims of "copper infused gloves" are complete nonsense. And the federal government is on to the scam.


In 2015 Tommy Copper reached a $1.35 million settlement for deceptive and fraudulent advertising. It’s just a matter of time until the Federal Trade Commission and Food and Drug Administration prohibit ALL false claims about copper infused "therapy" products.  

Use wrist braces with care

Many carpal tunnel patients first try treating their symptoms by buying a wrist brace from Walgreens, CVS, Walmart, etc. But like gloves, such braces are not designed to treat carpal tunnel syndrome.


In fact, like compression gloves, they can actually worsen your condition. This especially happens when you wear the wrong brace or wear one all the time.


Here's when and how to use wrist braces properly if you have carpal tunnel syndrome:

night brace

1. Never wear a wrist brace while working

Never wear a wrist brace when you're working with your hands. This is contrary to what many doctors tell their patients. But wearing a wrist brace while your hand is active during the day only makes the problem worse. Why?


With carpal tunnel syndrome, your wrist joint is already damaged. Restricting it's movement with a brace only causes you to fight the brace (subconsciously) while working. This causes double-stress (and double-damage) to the wrist.


Instead, it's much better to allow your wrist to be free, even though it may be bothersome. At least you're not causing more damage to your wrist and making your condition worse.

2. Only use a wrist brace at night

OK, if you have carpal tunnel syndrome you should NEVER wear a wrist brace during the day. However, you should ALWAYS wear a wrist brace while sleeping. The reason?


When we sleep, we all  unconsciously bend our hands backward. That "hyper-extension" is very bad if you have carpal tunnel syndrome. That's because hand hyper-extension causes compression of the median nerve inside your wrist joint.


However, a brace prevents such over-bending. Essentially, it allows your hand to rest while you sleep. But be sure you only wear a "certified carpal tunnel brace" at night (see below for explanation).

bad carpal tunnel brace

3. Beware the "palmar spine"

Do you wear a night brace but still have nighttime or morning symptoms? Chances are you're not wearing the proper brace.


Most ordinary wrist braces (found in CVS, Walmart, Walgreens, etc.) contain a metal spine on the palmar surface of the brace. This is called a "palmar spine" (see picture above). The spine acts as s stiffener to keep your hand in a straightened ("neutral") position as you sleep.


However, if you try bending your hand backward with a brace containing a palmar spine, the spine will push into your wrist joint. That increases the compression on the median nerve. And we already know that the median nerve is highly sensitive to such pressure changes.


But a "certified carpal tunnel brace" contains a spine on the lateral or dorsal side of the hand, not on the palmar surface (see picture below). That way, any hand movement does not cause compression on the median nerve.


So look for a "certified carpal tunnel brace" which does not contain a palmar spine. The most popular of such braces are listed below (priced highest to lowest at publication):


  1. AliMed Dorsal Resting Splint (approx. $138)
  2. BSOS Dorsal Splint (approx. $100)
  3. Comfy Dorsal Hand Orthosis (approx. $98)
  4. LEEDer Dorsal Orthosis (approx. $85)
  5. CarpalRx Night Brace (approx. $50)
  6. RCIA Dorsal Splint (approx. $48)
certified carpal tunnel brace

Conclusion

Carpal tunnel gloves are only slightly useful for fighting carpal tunnel syndrome. They don't do much except keep your hand warm. And warmth alone isn't going to eliminate symptoms.


Carpal tunnel syndrome isn't just an annoyance. It's an extremely common yet serious disorder of the hand. And unfortunately, there's no cheap or quick way out of it.


The answer to stopping carpal tunnel syndrome before it gets worse is to use real medical therapy that's applied every day for several weeks. Only this kind of dedication and persistence will eventually resolve symptoms permanently.


The alternative is to allow the condition to worsen week by week. And the longer it goes untreated, your symptoms will become more intense -- and more difficult to treat.



Which non-surgical therapies are best? 

 

 


It's important to note that the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons advises all patients to use the above remedies first, before considering surgery. These therapies are extremely effective in most patients in eliminating carpal tunnel symptoms for good.

Share by: