800-450-6118

What is "Severe" Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?

Dr. Z • Mar 22, 2020

What is "Severe" Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?

There's a huge difference between mild, moderate and severe carpal tunnel syndrome. Sure, pain or numbness in your fingers or hand might drive you crazy. And the feelings may be persistent or else pop up at inconvenient times. Any of these problems will likely rob you of a good night's sleep. 


While that's bad enough, it's not sufficient to categorize the condition as "severe". Believe it or not, severe carpal tunnel symptoms can be much worse.


Therefore, while you might think your symptoms are "severe", your doctor or hand surgeon might not. The general medical consensus it that "severe" means when carpal tunnel symptoms are so intense "They interfere with almost every aspect of your life." 


That also means:

 

Before you let carpal tunnel get to the severe stage, you should get help at the first sign there's something wrong. At the end of this article, you'll find various options for the successful treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome.


Young man deeply thinking.

What causes severe carpal tunnel syndrome?

Carpal tunnel syndrome is caused when the median nerve inside your wrist joint is compressed and ultimately crushed. The compression happens because deep inside the wrist joint, tendons and other nearby tissues thicken and inflame.  


Nobody is certain why the inflammation happens in some people but not in others. Scientists believe it may have something to do with how you physically use your hands. Repetitive stress injury is therefore one factor that's investigated a great deal.


Certain professions are infamous for having carpal tunnel syndrome. The most notable of these occupations include hairdressers, dental hygienists, guitar players, fine artists, knitters, graphic designers, and transcriptionists. Obviously, these and other professionals use their hands a lot and in different ways. But not everybody in these occupations gets this condition.

Bearded man thinking deeply about carpal tunnel.

Carpal tunnel syndrome also appears to have a genetic basis. If a close family member has (or had) carpal tunnel syndrome, then you're likely to get it as well. Once again, nobody is certain why.


Whatever brings on carpal tunnel syndrome, the result is the same. Tendons inside the wrist joint inflame, fill with fluid, and then swell. These swollen tendons contain so much fluid pressure that they push out against the adjacent median nerve. 


The build-up of pressure compresses the nerve more and more each day. Eventually, the compression is so great that the median nerve is completely crushed. 


This nerve compression causes various intensities of pain or numbness as the nerve gets crushed further and further. The resulting sensations are different from one person to the next. In fact, no two people have the exact same carpal tunnel symptoms. 

A pregnant brunette awakens with lower back pain.

How does carpal tunnel start?

Who gets it

Anybody can get carpal tunnel syndrome. Medical science is still unclear why some people get it when others do not.


What is known is there are certain risk factors associated with this condition. That means your probability of getting carpal tunnel syndrome is greater when you:


Attractive and fair-skinned mother and daughter pose cheek-to-cheek for a happy picture.

What carpal tunnel syndrome feels like

What carpal tunnel syndrome feels like from one person to the next is always a bit different. But symptoms usually follow a distinct pattern.


Most times, symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome start out gradually. Actually, most people don't even notice them in the beginning. For example, you may sense unusual feelings in your hand or fingers like tingling, numbness, burning or itching. Any of these  can happen in any finger except the little finger (pinky finger). They're often more intense in the thumb and index fingers. 


You might pass off these feelings as “over-tired hands”. You might think you just aggravated something or over-stressed your hands while doing simple tasks. That could be the case.  But it also might be the beginning of mild stage carpal tunnel syndrome. Neglecting these warning signs can be risky.


A big problem with mild carpal tunnel syndrome is that you don't feel the symptoms while working your hands. Instead, symptoms most often appear only when your hand is resting , like when you're trying to sleep. That makes you think it's not such a big deal.


In fact, the beginning (onset) symptoms seem more like an inconvenience while you're trying to sleep. Oftentimes, patients have to wake up to shake out their numb hands. Or sometimes pain will wake them up from a dead sleep. This stage usually lasts only a couple months. Then it progresses even further.

Young brunette woman having trouble opening a jar.

What are moderate stage symptoms?

If you do nothing to treat the signs of mild stage carpal tunnel syndrome, chances are good it will progress. That's when you enter the moderate stage of carpal tunnel syndrome. 


As the median nerve gets crushed even further, symptoms escalate. Patients feel the same symptoms as before, but now they're much more intense and constant. For instance, one of the most common new complaints is loss of grip strength. Such hand weakness is usually accompanied by dexterity problems


The other common symptoms people experience in the moderate stage are more intense:


Young brunette woman typing on a computer.

Sometimes brand new symptoms can appear in the moderate stage.  For example, some people may only have numbness when the condition starts out. Then the numbness worsens a lot more in the moderate stage. 


You may have either finger dexterity problems, hand clumsiness or hand weakness. But usually patients have a combination of all three of these issues.


As carpal tunnel syndrome gets more severe,  And patients may also feel a complete loss of finger dexterity.


As the condition advances through the moderate stage, pain may also enter the picture in you didn't have it to begin with. But this isn't a rule. 


Also, symptoms will also appear during the day . Most times they worsen while performing relatively innocent hand activities. Some of the more common hand activities where carpal tunnel seems to worsen are:

 

  • Using tools or utensils
  • Using a mouse or keyboard
  • Holding a steering wheel
  • Knitting or sewing
  • Playing video games
  • Holding a phone
  • Turning a doorknob
  • Washing dishes 
  • Lifting a baby
  • Playing sports
  • Playing a guitar or piano

 

Some people report their fingers feel swollen or puffy, even though they’re not.  At times patients feel these sensations in both hands simultaneously. This is called bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome, and it occurs in over 80% of patients.


The moderate stage of carpal tunnel syndrome can last for several months. Once your hands get to the moderate stage, the statistics are not in your favor. Without intervention, and in the coming weeks, over 90% of patients see symptoms intensify even more. This isn't the time to ignore those symptoms.

A seated man in nice clothes tying a shoelace.

Signs that severe carpal tunnel syndrome is starting

As the condition progresses past the moderate stage, you enter the stage of  severe carpal tunnel syndrome. This is when symptoms get so bad that patients usually seek professional help. 


Patients with severe symptoms often describe their sensations as "extreme".  The symptoms are so intense and all-consuming that they interfere with every aspect of life. Doctors often hear patients say...


"It's so bad I want to cut my hand (or finger) off!"


By now, finger or hand pain, numbness, tingling, weakness and burning are constant. There's no time interval when symptoms are not there. In other words, there's no rest or relief from them. You can't even sleep without these symptoms constantly waking you up several times a night. 


Patients often look back to a time when symptoms were merely annoying or bothersome. Now they're making work, sleep, play, and rest miserable or even impossible.


Also with severe carpal tunnel syndrome, it's common for patients to feel symptoms either radiate or "shoot" up the arm. Usually, it's the pain symptom that does this. And it might feel like shooting electric shocks. The forearm may even feel tender almost up to the elbow. In rarer cases, pain or tenderness can travel past the elbow, up the arm, and into the shoulder.


In the severe stage, most patients have catastrophic loss of finger dexterity and grip strength. They tend to drop things like drinking glasses or beverage bottles. Many find it impossible to perform simple tasks like opening a jar, picking up coins, buttoning a shirt, tying shoelaces or writing with a pen. Having the strength to turn a doorknob or open a car door is practically lost.


Personal grooming, washing, toileting, hygiene, and dressing becomes a real chore. Folding clothes or linens is next to impossible. Many parents must give up lifting their infant for fear of dropping the child. 


This is the very definition of severe carpal tunnel syndrome because it definitely  "interferes with your life". 


Believe it or not, it can get even worse! This is "advanced severe carpal tunnel syndrome". 

Location of thenar atrophy which comes with advanced severe carpal tunnel syndrome.

What is "advanced severe" carpal tunnel syndrome?

Just when you thought carpal tunnel couldn't get any worse, it does. Doctors call this advanced severe carpal tunnel syndrome. Some doctors more ominously call it end-stage carpal tunnel syndrome. This means, because there was no intervention, the condition progressed to its final, natural, inevitable, and incurable conclusion. 


Up until this point (during the severe stage), patients had the opportunity to do something in order to halt carpal tunnel's progression. It was even possible to reverse most of carpal tunnel's symptoms and restore their hand. That's because some parts of the median nerve were still alive and active during the severe stage. 


But once patients reach the advanced severe stage, the problem is usually not salvageable, much less reversible. Carpal tunnel doctors usually will not perform surgery at this point due to the high failure rate.

Burned fingers in a patient with loss of feeling due to carpal tunnel syndrome.

Surgeons also call this the hypo-atrophy stage, and for good reason. That's because there's significant muscle wasting at the base of the patient's thumb. It means there's no saving the thumb's muscle now.


That muscle is normally the thick bump between the wrist and thumb. When it wastes away, you can actually see the muscle has flattened out and became wrinkly. It signifies that most of the median nerve has died. As a result, the muscle it connects to (the thumb) no longer gets motor commands. As a result, the muscle degenerates and dies as well.


One of the most dangerous consequences of advanced severe carpal tunnel syndrome is losing the sensation of hot and cold. It's very common for patients to scald themselves with boiling water. Also, they often have severe burns from working on a hot stove. Many victims say they didn't notice a problem until they smelled burning flesh. 


Finally, useful hand and finger function is nearly gone at this late stage of the disorder. The fingers are unable to hold or pinch anything. They're in a constant "curled" state. This is called "claw hand" because of the claw-like deformity that results from severe carpal tunnel syndrome.


A sad but ironic phenomenon about severe advanced carpal tunnel syndrome is that pain symptoms may actually diminish. While numbness remains a crushing problem, patients generally feel better because there's finally some relief from pain's misery. But this is not a good thing. It means the median nerve is essentially dead and your hand doesn't work anymore.


From the standpoint of using your hand, at this point it's nearly a non-functioning appendage. You still might be able to feel things, but this sensory ability is greatly reduced. Unfortunately, hand weakness, loss of dexterity, and temperature insensitivity does improve. 

Claw hand in a patient with advanced severe carpal tunnel syndrome.

How do you treat severe carpal tunnel syndrome?

In most cases, even severe carpal tunnel syndrome can still be successfully treated (but not advanced severe carpal tunnel). The best remedies aim to relieve pressure on the median nerve. In most cases, relieving the surrounding fluid pressure can make the nerve plump up, and return to its normal self - or very close to it. 


When it comes to the treatment of severe carpal tunnel syndrome in the severe stage, doctors and patients consider 3 main factors.

 

  • How intense the symptoms are
  • The length of time you’ve had these symptoms
  • The degree to which these symptoms affect your life

 

You should never allow symptoms to advance so far that the numbness or pain is ruining your life before you seek treatment. Carpal tunnel syndrome is most difficult to treat at that time. But this unfortunate situation is what happens in many cases. 


Remember, severe carpal tunnel syndrome can still be treated, it's just more difficult to end up with good results. Ideally, you want to intervene in the mild stage in order to see good results.

Young blonde woman with a pained, miserable face due to severe carpal tunnel syndrome.

Carpal tunnel release surgery

The goal of carpal tunnel surgery is to de-compress the median nerve. All hand surgeons will advise you that the more advanced or intense your carpal tunnel, the less likelihood surgery will relieve symptoms. In other words, surgery has a higher failure rate with more severe symptoms.


Carpal tunnel release surgery can be performed using the endoscopic surgery method or the open release method. Each method has its pros and cons, and your doctor will choose which to use. Usually the doctor will specialize in one or the other method.


Whichever surgical method is used, the success rate of carpal tunnel release surgery is proportional to how severe your symptoms are at the time of surgery. 


Unfortunately, there are no good statistics to show the association between symptoms severity and surgical success rates. Therefore, ask your surgeon what his/her success rate is relative to having mild, moderate or severe symptoms. (Remember, advanced severe symptoms are usually deemed inoperable.)


Also make sure you ask the doctor for an answer that defines success as patient satisfaction  3 years after surgery.  Why? When combining all levels of severity, the published success rate of surgery is 50% patient satisfaction at year 3. 

A doctor performs myofascial release massage on the wrist to relieve carpal tunnel syndrome.

Non-surgical remedies

Unlike surgery, there's no downside to trying non-surgical remedies first. Actually, the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons as well as the National Institutes of Health recommend trying all non-surgical therapies before surgery is even discussed.


That's because non-surgical remedies work in the vast majority of patients. And they work at nearly every stage of carpal tunnel syndrome. How to treat the condition without surgery is therefore a major goal of doctors and therapists.


The best non-surgical techniques are usually described as " B.R.E.M. " This stands for Brace, Rest, Exercise, and Massage.


Brace

Brace your hand at night to help avoid over-bending your wrist. This will provide much-needed rest for your wrist joint. Moreover, make sure to sleep with a certified carpal tunnel brace. That means it's made specifically for carpal tunnel syndrome and not another condition like a sprained wrist or arthritis. As a matter of fact, such generic braces should not be used because they can aggravate your condition. Also, never brace your hand while it's working. A brace only makes you fight the restriction as your hand moves, making carpal tunnel syndrome even worse during the day.


Rest

Rest your hand often and insure you don’t do anything that could make the condition get even worse. Usually if your hand is relatively quiet for 3-4 weeks it will dramatically reduce symptoms. Also, take avoidance measures. For instance, take frequent breaks when sitting at a computer or using tools. And try to minimize or avoid the repetitive hand activity that made your hand sick to begin with.​​​​​​​ Many people find it's necessary to change jobs when they reach the stage of severe carpal tunnel syndrome. 

Young woman performs one of the key carpal tunnel stretching exercises

Exercise

Carpal tunnel syndrome exercises are among the best way to insure you never suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome to begin with. And if you have it, the proper hand and finger stretching exercises can reverse even severe symptoms. Stretching exercises for carpal tunnel syndrome break up restrictions and "un-stick" tendons while also helping to drain excess fluid from inside the wrist joint. The best carpal tunnel stretches target the flexor tendons in the fingers, hand, and wrists. Best of all, the most effective exercises take less than 60 seconds to complete. You must do these stretching exercises often, depending on how severe your symptoms are. The more exercises, the better.


Massage

Massage your wrist and forearm using myofascial release techniques. This is crucial in order to relieve the tendon inflammation that causes carpal tunnel syndrome. It’s highly effective at all stages of the condition, even at the severe stage. However, it must be performed twice a day  and for at least 4 weeks to see symptoms diminish. Unfortunately, you can't perform myofascial release massage on yourself because it requires two thumbs. So a willing partner who learns how to perform the massage is needed. A trained professional therapist can also provide this technique, but it would be much more costly than a partner.

Conclusions

Severe carpal tunnel syndrome occurs when the patient did not treat the condition early enough. The more advanced the symptoms, the more difficult it is to treat the condition effectively and get good results. Many people opt for carpal tunnel release surgery at this point. However, with any treatment - even surgery - the likelihood that symptoms will be reduced depends on three things. First, the severity of the condition. Second, how long you’ve had carpal tunnel syndrome. Third, how much these symptoms affect your life. These can guide you toward the type of remedy you should be looking for, and the results you might expect.

Share by: